Tuesday, November 17News That Matters

Mangroves and Forests Could Offer Cheaper, More Flexible Climate Protection Than Concrete, Study Finds

 

Nature based solutions such as mangrove forests, urban trees and restored watersheds could provide more affordable and adaptable protection against climate change than conventional infrastructure made from concrete and steel, according to recent research.

Governments commonly rely on seawalls, dams, dykes and drainage systems to protect communities from floods, rising sea levels and extreme weather. However, these structures can be expensive, difficult to modify and vulnerable to climate conditions they were not originally designed to withstand.

Researchers Andrew Lowe, Jasmin Packer and Robert Nasi argue that natural ecosystems should be treated as essential infrastructure because they can help protect homes, farms and cities while adapting to changing environmental conditions.

Concrete Infrastructure Faces Growing Challenges

Many traditional infrastructure systems were designed for a more stable climate. Rising sea levels and changing rainfall patterns are increasingly testing their limits.

Coastal defences built to withstand earlier storm surges are being breached more frequently, while intense rainfall can overwhelm drainage networks. Severe downpours in Jackson, Mississippi, in 2022 caused major water infrastructure failures, while intense cloudbursts in Saitama, Japan, this year turned streets into fast-flowing waterways.

Unlike rigid structures, natural ecosystems can adjust to changing temperatures, rainfall and sediment conditions.

New York City demonstrated the financial benefits of this approach in the 1990s, when authorities invested approximately A$2.1 billion in protecting forests and vegetation in the city’s watershed. This helped avoid the construction of a conventional water filtration plant estimated to cost between US$8.6 billion and US$11 billion.

Mangroves Can Reduce Coastal Flood Risks

Tropical countries face significant threats from rising sea levels because they contain more than 60% of the world’s low-lying coastlines.

Even with substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, sea levels could rise approximately 0.6 metres by 2100 compared with 2000 levels. If emissions are not sharply reduced, the increase could reach around 2.2 metres.

Without effective adaptation measures, rising seas could cause more than US$27 trillion in global damage.

Mangrove forests offer a natural and cost-effective way to reduce coastal risks. Their dense root systems help weaken storm surges and limit flooding. Existing mangrove forests are estimated to provide protection worth around A$1.2 trillion over 100 years.

Planting mangroves generally costs less than half as much as building equivalent concrete and steel coastal defences. The property damage avoided through mangrove protection can be 10 to 100 times greater than the planting costs.

In Vietnam’s Mekong Delta, authorities are combining traditional embankments with mangrove belts to extend the lifespan of coastal structures and reduce maintenance expenses. Forests also function as natural water infrastructure. They filter rainwater, protect watersheds and contribute to the recycling of moisture that supports regional rainfall.

The Brazilian Amazon’s role in rainfall and water recycling is estimated to be worth approximately US$20 billion annually. These natural processes support agriculture, electricity generation and regional water supplies.

Forests are particularly important for countries that depend heavily on hydropower. Deforestation increases soil erosion, allowing more sediment to enter rivers and accumulate in reservoirs. This can reduce the capacity of hydropower dams and affect electricity generation.

Urban Trees Help Cities Beat Extreme Heat

Urban areas often experience higher temperatures than surrounding regions because concrete, bricks and asphalt absorb and retain heat. This urban heat island effect can increase health risks, particularly in rapidly growing cities.

Street trees, green corridors and urban forests provide shade and cooling, helping reduce heat related illnesses and electricity demand.

Singapore’s plan to plant one million trees by 2030 is projected to reduce outdoor heat stress by 3–5°C and lower summer air conditioning energy use by 6–9%.

In Colombia, green corridors along roads and waterways have reduced average temperatures by approximately 2°C. The initiative is estimated to generate US$1.70 in avoided health costs for every US$1 invested.

Despite its environmental and economic benefits, investment in nature based infrastructure remains limited. Existing government procurement systems often favour conventional construction because engineering standards and contracts for concrete and steel projects are already well established.

Researchers say these systems frequently fail to account for the wider benefits of healthy ecosystems, including flood protection, water services and reduced climate related damage.

They recommend four key changes:

1. Recognise green infrastructure as a capital asset in national planning systems, with the same status as conventional infrastructure.

2. Protect existing forests, mangroves and other natural assets before considering new concrete-based construction.

3. Include the economic value of healthy ecosystems in project assessments and investment decisions.

4. Design major development projects using a combination of green and grey infrastructure suited to future climate conditions.

The researchers conclude that political resistance and established infrastructure practices remain major barriers to wider adoption. However, as climate-related damage increases, governments will need to reconsider how they invest in long-term protection.

Nature based infrastructure is not simply an environmental alternative they argue, but an essential and often more affordable way to build climate resilience.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *