As air pollution in Delhi continues to reach severe levels during winter, the government is preparing to conduct another round of cloud seeding trials in an attempt to improve air quality. However experts have cautioned that the technique may offer little relief in the absence of suitable moisture rich clouds and could even worsen pollution if it produces only light drizzle.
The Delhi government announced plans to conduct cloud seeding trials over the national capital in the coming days, depending on prevailing weather conditions. Two trials were also conducted before Diwali. Similar experiments were carried out last winter, but they failed to deliver the expected improvement in air quality.
Why Cloud Seeding May Not Work in Winter
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique in which substances such as silver iodide, dry ice or sodium chloride are introduced into existing clouds to encourage water droplets to form and grow, potentially triggering rainfall.
However, the process requires suitable clouds containing sufficient moisture. Gufran Beig, chair professor at the National Institute of Advanced Studies and founder of the System of Air Quality and Weather Forecasting & Research, questioned the feasibility of the Delhi trials without appropriate cloud conditions.
He explained that moisture-rich clouds are generally more common during the pre-monsoon period and sometimes after the monsoon, making winter cloud seeding operations challenging.
Beig also warned that light rainfall may be counterproductive. While heavy rain can wash pollutants out of the atmosphere, isolated showers or drizzle may not provide enough precipitation to clean the air. During winter, drizzle can instead coincide with a rise in pollution levels.
Light Rain May Not Remove PM2.5 Effectively
Particulate matter, particularly PM2.5, has emerged as a major pollutant in Delhi during and after Diwali, according to Central Pollution Control Board data.
Beig said that heavy rainfall can reduce PM2.5 and PM10 concentrations by washing particles out of the atmosphere. The effectiveness of this process depends partly on rainfall intensity.
He cautioned that light drizzle may leave fine particles suspended in the air. These particles can interact with water droplets remaining in the atmosphere, potentially contributing to higher pollution concentrations.
S T Aruna, chief scientist at CSIR-National Aerospace Laboratories in Bengaluru, noted that rainfall can help reduce certain pollutants, but its impact varies. Pollutants such as carbon monoxide, for example, are not significantly affected by rain.
Beig also said that the chemicals used in cloud seeding are generally introduced in small quantities and normally break down before reaching the ground.
Experts emphasised that cloud seeding cannot address the underlying sources of Delhi’s pollution. Vehicular and industrial emissions, construction related pollution and stubble burning in neighbouring States continue to contribute to poor air quality, particularly during winter.
Aruna said cloud seeding could serve as an emergency measure if it successfully produces rainfall, but it cannot become a sustainable pollution control strategy while major emission sources remain unchecked.
She recommended stronger measures, including incentives for farmers to discourage stubble burning, greater use of renewable energy, continuous emissions monitoring and satellite based tracking of fires. Industrial facilities, power plants and brick kilns should also be equipped with systems to control emissions of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides.
Beig stressed that air pollution does not follow city or administrative boundaries and requires sincere coordination among Delhi and neighbouring States.
Delhi has already introduced measures such as vehicle restrictions, promotion of public transport and expansion of electric vehicles. However, experts believe that coordinated regional action and sustained reductions in emissions are essential for lasting improvements.
The overall assessment is that cloud seeding may provide temporary relief under favourable weather conditions, but it cannot replace long-term policies aimed at controlling pollution at its source.
